November 20, 2026

"I Want to Walk Hand in Hand With My Wife": Jeff Johnston's Goal Digger Story

Author

Laine Johnson

Share

Jeff Johnston spent more than 20 years in ministry as a youth pastor and Christian school principal. He used to run 18 to 25 mile Spartan races, and, in his own words, reads way too much. After a car wreck that resulted in an above the knee amputation, he wrote one goal on his card: walk hand in hand with his wife, Karen. He reached it two days after getting his first prosthetic leg. Since then, he's been setting and reaching goals. Now he's working toward 21 days of running!


Goal Number One

Jeff received his first prosthesis on April 1, 2022. Yes, April Fools' Day. For a guy who can't go five minutes without cracking a joke, the timing was perfect.


"What a convenient day for me," he said.


The next morning, the family drove to Hilton Head for spring break. The first night was rough. His beloved Duke basketball team was losing to North Carolina in Coach K's last game, Jeff was still getting used to his new leg, and he spent the evening frustrated and angry.


The following day, Jeff was reading Marcus Aurelius and came across a line that stopped him: don't ever be overheard complaining, even by yourself. He decided he was done complaining for the day. If he wasn't able to do the things he wanted to with his new leg yet, he would just keep trying.


Later that day, out on the condo's long walkway, he set his crutches to the side and took a few steps on his own.


Jeff's wife, Karen, was nearby, and Jeff knew exactly what he wanted to do next. Since the wreck, walkers and crutches had kept his hands full, and he hadn't been able to hold hers. He called her out onto the walkway.


"I told her, I'm like, come here, come here, hold my hand," Jeff said.


On April 3, 2022, two days after getting his first prosthesis, Jeff and Karen walked hand in hand.


"And I'm like, goal number one, done," stated Jeff.

A Birthday Text to Dad

Getting to that walkway took a year and a half.


October 22, 2020, was Jeff's dad's birthday. Jeff was leaving early that morning to pick up a coworker for a conference in Baltimore, so the night before, he texted his dad: happy birthday early, I love you, I'll call you later. It's the last thing he remembers.


About five miles from home, on the same road he drove the kids to school every day, Jeff collided with a dump truck in Karen's Highlander. The impact ejected him through the windshield and into a grassy, wooded area beside the road. On the way out, his leg caught in the wreckage, which likely kept him from hitting the dump truck head first.


When the sheriff's deputy arrived, he believed Jeff did not make it due to his significant injuries and the appearance of the accident. Then a bystander held a small mirror to Jeff's mouth. When she saw it fog up, she shouted, "He is alive!"


Karen was driving their two children, Ryan and Katelyn, to school that morning when she came up on heavy traffic and took another way. After drop-off, Jeff's coworker called Karen and said Jeff never showed up to his house to pick him up for their trip. Karen turned down a tiny back road that led her straight to the scene of the accident, where a state trooper confirmed it was Jeff. All he could tell her was that Jeff was alive when the ambulance left.

Karen can't remember seeing the Highlander that day, even though others with her did.


Regarding Karen not seeing the Highlander, Jeff said, "I still think God was like, No, you don't need to see that right now."


At the hospital, doctors found an aortic aneurysm and rushed him into surgery. The vascular surgeon believed she reached it within minutes of it rupturing, saving Jeff's life. Following surgery, Jeff spent days on life support with a brain bleed, broken ribs, a broken collarbone, and a leg with more fractures than anyone could count. He doesn't remember the first 13 days after the accident in the hospital. He likes to think he finally woke up because so many people were praying for him over their lunches, tacking on a quick "and help my friend Jeff." And because it was 2020, COVID rules meant Ryan and Katelyn were never able to visit him inside the hospital.




A Leg That Wouldn't Bend

His surgeon saved his leg, in part because Jeff was in great shape and he believed Jeff would put in the work.


But his knee would never bend after the accident. That December, a procedure to break up scar tissue tore his quad from his hip almost to his knee, and Jeff began internally bleeding in his leg without anyone realizing it.


A scan finally found the bleeding, and an emergency surgery saved his life again.

Jeff on a therapy table using a strap to work on bending his knee

In February, doctors found heterotopic ossification, which meant muscle in his leg was turning to bone.


"It sounds cool in the comic books, but it is not worth it in real life to have muscle turn to bone," Jeff said.


After 15 surgeries, 11 of them on his leg, he never got his knee past 31 degrees. From late 2020 until August of 2021, Jeff lived in a bed in the family's living room. Karen slept beside him on a tiny couch they found on Facebook Marketplace, just in case he needed anything in the night.


For months he couldn't lift his leg on his own. Karen, Ryan, and Katelyn lifted it so he could get out of bed, and he hopped his walker to the bathroom by himself.


"I didn't want anybody to help me go to the bathroom. I'm like I wanted some dignity," he said.

In August of 2021, Jeff asked his surgeon a simple question: what about amputation? His surgeon told him he'd been waiting for Jeff to bring it up, that the choice had to be Jeff's, and that he believed Jeff would have a better quality of life.


"Once he said that, my decision was made," Jeff said.


He sent Jeff home to pray about it. After a year of spending birthdays and holidays in the hospital, he also had Jeff wait until after Christmas to be sure.


Before the Decision

While Jeff was still deciding on if he was going to go through with the amputation, a friend, who was already a patient of Alliance Prosthetics + Orthotics, invited him along to one of his appointments. That's where he met Jason Auyer, Owner of Alliance and Clinical Director, before his scheduled amputation.


Jeff made the final decision with his surgeon, and in January, he set the date for his amputation. When the day came, he knew he wanted Alliance on his care team afterward.



The X on His Leg

Jeff had his amputation on January 24, 2022. He went into the morning in good spirits, joking around for Karen's sake and ready to start the next chapter. Then a nurse came in with a marker and drew an X on his left leg.


"I looked at my wife, and we locked eyes, and she teared up and started crying, and I teared up and started crying," Jeff said.


After surgery, he lifted what was left of his leg for the first time.


"You know how when you think you have coffee in a mug, and you go to pick it up, but there's nothing in it, and it's like, really light. That's how it felt."


The evening following his amputation, a clinician from our team stopped by his hospital room on her way to dinner to drop off information and check in on him, rather than waiting until the next day.


"I remember thinking, if that's the kind of people that are gonna be taking care of me, that's who I'm gonna go with," Jeff said.


Of all 15 surgeries, Jeff says the amputation was the easiest. He was home in two days.


"My mindset from that point on is like, okay, let's figure this out," he said.



The Whole Family Was Welcomed

From his very first prosthetic leg fitting, Jeff noticed his whole family was welcomed by Alliance, not just himself.


"They didn't just treat my wife like she was a nameless attachment. They asked, Do you want any water? Are you okay? How have you been doing?"


Looking back, Jeff credits his support system and the grace of God for getting him through.


"God shows His grace through people. He works through people. So it's been really good to have the people that I have," he said.



Jeff, Karen, and their two kids dressed up and standing with two members of our team

The Patient We Had to Slow Down

Jason likes to say some people need a nudge to put their leg on, and some need to be pulled back. Jeff was in the second group. Two weeks after his amputation, he was wearing his leg 12 to 13 hours a day, and a clinician from our team had to remind him to build up an hour at a time.


His goals started out just as big. Jeff's very first one was to run a 5K just three months after his amputation. Jason encouraged him to start small and build from there.


So the day he received his prosthesis, Jeff wrote down a goal that looked small on paper and meant everything to him: stand on his own and hold Karen's hand.


Two days later, on a Hilton Head walkway, he checked it off.



Jeff and Karen in our clinic in front of the mission statement, Jeff's prosthetic leg visible

Small Victories, Then Bigger Ones

After Hilton Head came getting to the shower without crutches, climbing the stairs by himself, and swimming again. In August 2022, his physical therapist told him he could put the cane away for good.


"I didn't need crutches, walker, cane, I could walk like a human being," Jeff said. "It was such a huge milestone for me."


All that work made him our 2021/22 Goal Digger of the Year!


Jeff is honest that the years after weren't all forward. He took on a demanding job, and his rehab slid to the back burner. This year, he and Karen decided it was time to put his health first again.


Pain is still part of every day. A surgeon once told him it always would be, so Jeff read everything he could from Navy SEALs and the Stoics about living with it.


"You're just gonna have pain. It's gonna be uncomfortable," he said.



Jeff speaking into a microphone on stage, holding his Goal Digger of the Year plaque

Even so, 2026 has been a big year. For about a year and a half, Jeff had been trying to walk two laps around Rock Creek, the park near his house, a little over two miles. A low socket fit or a blister kept stopping him short. When he finally did it, he sent screenshots to friends and family.


"I never thought I'd be happy to walk around a park twice," he said.


He's also taken up swimming, since it's easy on the knee and hip that now do extra work. He's fallen in love with it, and on a dare, he even swam across Lake Lanier.



Jeff with trekking poles on a wooden overlook in front of a waterfall
Three goal cards: I am able to do 2 laps around Rock Creek, I am able to swim 2.02 miles, and I was able to hike Anna Ruby Falls

"My wife and I, we have a love that we never would have experienced without tragedy like that."

JEFF JOHNSTON



Karen and the Kids

Jeff's mom passed away on July 4, 2020, just a few months before the wreck. In her last years, his dad cared for her every day, and Jeff saw a kind of love between them that only came from going through hard things together. Now he says he and Karen have that same love.


When the wreck happened, Jeff's son, Ryan, was in ninth grade and his daughter, Katelyn, was in eighth. They had just moved to Georgia and were still settling into a new school. Both are in college now, and Jeff says watching them grow into such caring people is what he's proudest of. His dad, 77, is cheering from Albuquerque.

Jeff, Karen, Ryan, and Katelyn dressed up and smiling together

Karen says her hardest part was letting people help.


"That was probably the hardest thing for me was actually accepting help from people," she said.


Jeff says he wouldn't change the wreck if he could. Karen strongly disagrees. She'd ban every dump truck from the road if she could. But Jeff sees what it gave him, not just what it took.


"The fact that my leg is missing is sometimes a symbol to me that I'm alive," he said.


Words for Someone Just Starting

We asked Jeff what he'd tell someone starting right where he started.


"Take a day at a time, and look at the small victories."


He'd also tell them to speak up. Jeff is a people pleaser by nature, and he learned the hard way that being the nice guy who never complains can mean nobody hears you when something is really wrong.


"Take a breath and clearly and specifically state not just what you're thinking and what you're feeling, but what you know," he said.


His next piece of advice came from that rough night at Hilton Head: complaining feels good for a minute, but the problem is still there in the morning. And his last?


"Don't be lazy. It takes work."



What's Next for Jeff

These days, Jeff's at the driving range every third Thursday with an adaptive golf group, alongside a fellow Alliance patient he met at our running clinic.


Running is where Jeff has been putting in the work. At our first ever running clinic in 2026, he showed up with a goal written on his card: jog for three minutes straight. He met it that same day.



Jeff swinging a golf club on a driving range, his prosthetic leg visible

Now Jeff has a new running leg and a bigger goal.


"My goal is literally just 21 days of just getting out there and running, even if it's just 10 feet," he said.


And that 5K? It's still on his list.


After that, he wants to write a book. Karen already has a working title: Dump Truck Diaries.


"It's gonna be hard, but you just gotta do it. And if you keep that mentality, it just gets better."

JEFF JOHNSTON



Jeff holding his goal card on a football field, and Jeff running on a track with his coach beside him

Jeff survived a wreck no one at the scene thought he would, then spent more than a year with a leg that wouldn't bend before choosing amputation. Two days after getting his first prosthesis, he was holding Karen's hand on a Hilton Head walkway. Now he's lacing up for 21 days of running, and we can't wait to see where his goals take him next!


What's Your Goal?

Every device we make at Alliance Prosthetics + Orthotics starts with one question: what are you trying to get back to? Tell us what you're working toward, and we'll help you figure out the rest.


(770) 679-3090 · alliancepo.com


We're in Gainesville, Braselton, and Mulberry.